broox

Cable modems: buy or rent?

via Twitter and Facebook

facebook comments

  • i bought one for like $65 on Amazon, have had no problems. Paid for itself in less than a year from rental cost from Mediacom.

    Nick Leeper posted

  • The only reason I still rent is that the ones I rent from Mediacom seem to need replaced at least once a year... Curious if it's because their shit sucks, they're accidentally bricking them OTA, or if they just fail that often.

    Derek Brooks posted

  • We bought a dual band at Best Buy for $100 and it has been amazing!!!

    Karrie Neill Anderson posted

  • Afaik buying is the way to go.

    Daniel Salinas posted

  • I bought mine. Payback was 20 months. Had it three years with no issues. Had to purchase from our cable provider due to signal. Greg

    Greg Rankin posted

  • Buy.

    Scott Harrington posted

  • alright, so i'm apparently slow to the punch on this one. just bought the wirecutter recommendation (Arris SURFboard SB6183)

    Derek Brooks posted

  • Only problem with buying is if you have any issues with your internet the technician can not touch your modem what so ever not even to reset it and if it is a problem with the modem the price to fix the it goes up extremely.

    Nick Johnson posted

  • Plus getting the modem from the provider means you get the correct hardware for the bandwidth they are providing. It depends on the package you buy. If you are getting the 100 meg download package you want to make sure you are getting the correct modem for the speeds and the signal.

    Nick Johnson posted

  • When I had mediacom I bought. Fine for five plus years until I moved. Mediacom has a list of approved modems that work best with their stuff as well. Not sure if it makes a difference.

    Nathan Deutmeyer posted

  • Buy. Mediacom is the devil

    Rico Larson posted

  • charter includes it in our service no seperate line item its the same price either way

    Cliff Wynne posted

  • rent. Those things break.

    Chirag Patel posted

  • I buy, you can get good asus ones(better than the mediacom ones) that have good reliability and warranty. They are in the $100s range but pay themselves off since you wont be paying a "leasin fee" to mediacom.

    The last one i got ~3 years ago still runs fine.

    Netgear NightHawk R7000 is the one i use, got it for $150ish when it was on sale.

    Wesley Ng posted

  • Yep, rent. I always bought but then as they become obsolete and things...you have to "buy" new. Rent, then just complain it's slow or not working and get the newest one

    Dustin Iverson posted

twitter comments

  • buy

    CLINT posted

  • buy. pays for itself in a few months.

    iandees posted

  • @broox @iandees We used to have similar problems until buying the @wirecutter rec several years ago. Never renting a modem again.

    ejacqui posted

  • I bought, though now gigabit is available but requires rental.

    hhhealthy posted

  • @ejacqui @iandees @wirecutter Just bought the wirecutter modem

    broox posted

your comments